Design & Publishing _/_ WEB _/_ The Web Design & Review Reader Critique Index _/_ You are reading a reader review

Reader Reviews of Web Sites

Fred follows up on
Joyce's review of
Furry Tree Punk & Metal
Fan Zine


I want to give the devil his dues, here Joyce. YES Tripod spam is the pits -- it caused Darren's site to clock in at 48 seconds to first content (28.8 at 6 am EST) and little change... down to 32 seconds (ISDN 128K 6:15 am). So you see Darren, Tripod is killing you in terms of load time. (They should NOT be busy at that time of the morning, but the ad was 39K !)
__ But Joyce, it's a generation thing... my kids (both teens) probably listen to these groups, and as I watch them surf I realize they never even see the spam. CLICK and it's gone. Max has gotten so good he knows it's coming -- watch very closely -- he seems to click even BEFORE the window comes up! WHOA, wish I were that fast... must be youth?
__ One thing I know for sure. They WILL NOT READ that text. (above) Period. They'll get rid of that text almost as fast as the spam! Y'know why? Because it looks like work...

They won't read it if it looks like work!

__ I want to focus on the structure of the site. There are very obvious problems with the implementation -- problems which really stand in the way of reader "experience".
__ Dropping into a content area (shown above) we're met with this overpowering left bar layout, with terribly difficult to read typography. Darren, you've got to get your text

a) away from the border, and
b) easier to read.

Make the column width about half as wide. Kick the type to "normal" or "4" setting.
__ I know, it's very trendy to do ugly type, and most will say it's well positioned for the readership. But I challange you to get with some of your target market and quietly watch as they surf the site. (Wired Magazine used to brag that their type was all but unreadable. Have you seen Wired today?) Your content is no good if no one wants to read it.

Now... let's look at another page...

<- Back to the Reviews Index . / . Web Design & Review Front Page . / .Design Center News ->

Submit your website for review . / . Select a Web site and share your views

Note: If you would like to contact the reviewer, please copy the reference into a request.



Become a WebDesign reviewer, or have your site reviewed...
If you would like to do more than just a casual online form review, perhaps with examples, screen shots and make-over suggestions, please contact us. A good eye for design is hard to find, and many people can learn from your input. In exchange for your efforts, the site owner will thank you, and you'll be recognized by all the readers of WebDesign & Review. To get started, forward your first review overview, or proposal directly to: Be sure to include the URL of the website you are reviewing. You can POST your review by using the Website Review Form as well. If you'd like to publish tips, tricks, reviews, opinions, or otherwise share your expertise in the pages of WebDesign & Review then capture and read our "Readers Guidelines".

VIEWS EXPRESSED IN READER REVIEWS ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE VIEWS OR OPINIONS OF WEB DESIGN & REVIEW. WHEN READING THESE REVIEWS PLEASE REMEMBER THAT THE SITE MAY HAVE BEEN UPDATED OR RENNOVATED SINCE THE REVIEW WAS WRITTEN. ALL WEB SITE REVIEWS ARE OPINION BASED AND SHOULD BE ACCEPTED AS THAT. REVIEWS ARE IN NO WAY INTENDED TO RECOMMEND ANY SITE. THEY ARE INTENDED TO BE VIEWED AS LEARNING TOOLS FOR IMPROVEMENT. Thank you for visiting WebDesign & Review at Notes: The screen shots herein represent the copyrighted works of their respective owners, and are used here for editorial demonstration purposes. Permission has been granted to display and review all sites in WebDesign & Review by the website owners. Please read and be aware of our Legal Properties & Disclaimers document. Not all areas of the online environment allow special characters such as the registration and trademark marks. This file will alert you to proprietary works that cannot be duplicated or distributed. Copyright 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999 Showker Graphic Arts, for the The Design & Publishing Center, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. WebDesign & Review, Pixelsmith, WebEye are all trademarks for The Design & Publishing Center. Other products mentioned in these pages are the registered trademarks of their respective owners.